Skip to content Skip to footer

Critics Deride Norfolk Southern’s Newly Released 6-Point “Safety Plan”

Critics say we need robust federal action, not corporate “safety plans” aimed at further reducing the workforce.

A video screenshot released by the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) showing the site of a derailed freight train in East Palestine, Ohio, on February 3, 2023.

With railroad operator Norfolk Southern involved in numerous significant train derailments and other accidents in recent weeks, the company on Monday unveiled a “six-point safety plan” that officials claimed would “immediately enhance the safety of its operations.”

But critics including rail workers were quick to point out that one aspect of the plan could worsen the growing problem of reduced railroad crews, which they say has contributed to dangerous conditions on railroads.

The plan calls for a number of improvements to Norfolk Southern’s systems to detect overheated wheel bearings, which the National Transportation Safety Board said in a preliminary report appeared to be the cause of the train derailment in East Palestine, Ohio on February 3.

In addition, Norfolk Southern said it aims to accelerate its “digital train inspection program” by partnering with Georgia Tech Research Institute to develop new safety inspection technology the company claims could “identify defects and needed repairs much more effectively than traditional human inspection.”

The technology would use “machine vision and algorithms powered by artificial intelligence,” the plan reads — offering what journalist Sam Sacks said is likely a thinly veiled proposal for “further reductions” in the company’s workforce.

As Common Dreams reported last month, the national inter-union organization Railroad Workers United (RWU) has called for comprehensive legislation and robust action from regulators to keep rail workers and communities safe, warning that rail companies including Norfolk Southern have been lobbying for years for federal approval to reduce train crews and loosen safety protocols.

Rather than rail companies developing safety plans themselves, federal action is needed to guarantee “proper and adequate maintenance and inspection of rail cars and locomotives, track, signals, and other infrastructure, RWU co-chair Gabe Christenson said in a statement Monday.

Rail workers have “predicted stuff like” an increased reliance on automation, railroad worker and RWU steering committee member Matt Weaver told Common Dreams on Tuesday, as “the Precision Scheduled Railroading [PSR] business model” used by rail companies “calls for doing more with less.”

Under PSR, rail companies attempt to maximize profits by running trains on strict schedules and cutting back on equipment and staff. Railroad unions have said the system and the resulting lax safety protocols are an underlying cause of recent train accidents including the East Palestine derailment, another derailment that took place in Michigan less than two weeks later, and a collision between a Norfolk Southern train and a dump truck on Tuesday in Ohio, in which conductor Louis Shuster was killed.

Weaver noted that RWU and his own union, the Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes Division (BMWED), aren’t opposed to the use of automation in inspections entirely.

“We used to have 12-man gangs that put all the ties in by hand and everything, and now we have lots of machines which do help us live longer and not have our backs or our hips, knees, shoulders [get injured],” he told Common Dreams. “But you can’t just replace the manpower with a machine when it’s not always as effective. Eyes on the rails and the tracks can catch some things the machines do not.”

“We’ve accepted those as additional help,” he added. “Not as a replacement.”

Last year, as railroad companies including Norfolk Southern demanded that the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) allow them to continue pilot programs testing automated safety inspections, BMWED noted that according to FRA data, the causes of 48 train accidents that took place between 2016 and 2021 could only be detected through visual inspections while just 14 could be detected through “enhanced track geometry inspection” done by machines.

“Over 50% of the accidents that happened from 2016 to 2021 do not even have the ability to be found by the technology that they’re looking to use,” Roy Morrison, director of safety for the union, told Freight Waves last May.

In recent days rail unions have denounced an attempt by Norfolk Southern to use workers’ demands for paid sick leave against them — offering BMWED members four days of sick leave in exchange for the union’s support for its automated inspection program.

“Norfolk Southern’s proposal was ultimately for the union to be complicit in Norfolk Southern’s effort to reduce legally required minimum track safety standards through supporting their experimental track inspection program without a sensible fail-safe or safety precautions to help ensure trains would not derail,” wrote Jonathon Long, general chairman of the American Rail System Federation of the BMWED, in a letter to Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine. “In other words, Norfolk Southern’s proposal was to use your community’s safety as their bargaining chip to further pursue their record profits under their cost-cutting business model.”

Weaver argued that strong comprehensive railroad safety legislation is needed to compel railroad companies to keep workers and communities safe. RWU has expressed support for some aspects of the bipartisan Railway Safety Act of 2023, introduced last week, but warned that loopholes will allow companies to “avoid the scope of the law without violating the law” and ultimately use the legislation to reduce staff.

“That’s kind of their ultimate goal,” Weaver told Common Dreams. “And you can’t trust a capitalist industry, a for-profit industry to self-regulate. We have to have government intervention. So it’s time for the regulators to regulate and the public servants to serve the public.”

We have 5 days to raise $39,000 — we’re counting on your support!

For those who care about justice, liberation and even the very survival of our species, we must remember our power to take action.

We won’t pretend it’s the only thing you can or should do, but one small step is to pitch in to support Truthout — as one of the last remaining truly independent, nonprofit, reader-funded news platforms, your gift will help keep the facts flowing freely.