The Senate parliamentarian, an unelected functionary tasked with interpreting the upper chamber’s rules, advised Democrats late Thursday to exclude an immigration reform plan from their faltering Build Back Better package — a recommendation that progressives and rights groups said should be readily dismissed.
Parliamentarian Elizabeth MacDonough, a former Immigration and Naturalization Services (INS) prosecutor who worked on detention and deportation matters, argued that Democrats’ plan to temporarily shield millions of undocumented immigrants from deportation and extend work permits runs afoul of Senate rules that require all provisions of a reconciliation bill to have a direct impact on the federal budget.
While MacDonough’s opinion is non-binding — and, according to experts, wrong on the merits — the Senate with few exceptions has adhered to parliamentarian rulings in the past, a trend that progressive lawmakers and immigrant rights advocates said must be broken.
In her capacity as presiding officer of the Senate, Vice President Kamala Harris has the constitutional authority to overrule the parliamentarian, power that the Biden White House refused to wield after the official advised against raising the federal minimum wage to $15 an hour and other Democratic proposals earlier this year.
“The parliamentarian is not an elected official. Their guidance is advisory not law,” said Rep. Jamaal Bowman (D-N.Y.), who pointed to the Senate GOP’s decision in 2001 to terminate then-Parliamentarian Robert Dove after he issued a pair of recommendations that imperiled the party’s tax cuts for the rich, which ultimately became law.
“Democrats must overrule the parliamentarian to pass immigration reform,” Bowman added.
Erika Andiola, chief advocacy officer for the Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, said in a statement late Thursday that “MacDonough’s anti-immigrant ruling is a surprise to no one,” citing her past as an INS prosecutor.
“Now, we need Democrats to do something they have routinely failed to do under the current administration and the previous Democratic administrations: Grow a backbone and wage a real fight to protect our communities,” said Andiola. “Despite the ruling today, Democrats still have numerous avenues and the tools needed to deliver safety to the millions of immigrants living in daily uncertainty. There is no excuse for inaction.”
“Senate Democrats have the power to deliver on protection for immigrants if they have the courage to lead now,” Andiola continued. “Senate Majority Leader, Chuck Schumer, and Vice President Kamala Harris can overrule the parliamentarian, fire the parliamentarian, or abolish the filibuster. President Biden can use executive action to protect our communities. There’s no excuse.”
No. A “we tried, but the Parliamentarian…” is not gonna fly. Democrats said over and over again when 45 was president that they were the party that had our backs. I remember all those statements. All those campaign promises. Now it’s time to show it. #KeepThePromise
— Erika Andiola (@ErikaAndiola) December 17, 2021
MacDonough’s new advisory opinion represents the third time in recent months that she has deemed immigration reform proposals in violation of the Senate’s arcane reconciliation rules, which analysts and lawmakers argue are open to a wide range of interpretations.
“The parliamentarian’s opinion is incorrect on immigration,” Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) declared. “There’s a clear budgetary impact and years of precedent for immigration policy changes through reconciliation. We must pursue all options to deliver a path to citizenship, including for Dreamers and essential workers.”
Despite mounting grassroots pressure, Senate Democratic leaders have not clearly signaled they would support overruling the parliamentarian on immigration or any other matter she is set to offer advice on in the coming days.
In a joint statement Thursday evening, Schumer and Sens. Dick Durbin (D-Ill.), Bob Menendez (D-N.J.), Catherine Cortez Masto (D-Nev.), Ben Ray Luján (D-N.M.), and Alex Padilla (D-Calif.) said that “we strongly disagree with the Senate parliamentarian’s interpretation of our immigration proposal, and we will pursue every means to achieve a path to citizenship in the Build Back Better Act.”
“Throughout the entire reconciliation process, we have worked to ensure that immigration reform was not treated as an afterthought,” the senators said. “The majority of Americans support our efforts to provide legal status for millions of undocumented immigrants in the United States because it would raise wages, create good-paying jobs, enrich our economy, and improve the lives of all Americans.”
The parliamentarian’s recommendation Thursday was the latest hammer blow that Democrats’ flagship reconciliation package suffered this week, most of them inflicted by Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.), who is attempting to gut the expanded child tax credit and has removed a provision aimed at permanently banning new drilling off the Atlantic and Pacific coasts.
“This is a tragic milestone in the seemingly inevitable dismantling of the Build Back Better Act,” Brett Hartl, government affairs director at the Center for Biological Diversity, said of the death of the drilling provision.
That Manchin “wants to poison our coasts while he lives the good life in his landlocked state,” Hartl added, “only shows just how out of touch he is with the overwhelming public support for ending offshore drilling.”
Help us Prepare for Trump’s Day One
Trump is busy getting ready for Day One of his presidency – but so is Truthout.
Trump has made it no secret that he is planning a demolition-style attack on both specific communities and democracy as a whole, beginning on his first day in office. With over 25 executive orders and directives queued up for January 20, he’s promised to “launch the largest deportation program in American history,” roll back anti-discrimination protections for transgender students, and implement a “drill, drill, drill” approach to ramp up oil and gas extraction.
Organizations like Truthout are also being threatened by legislation like HR 9495, the “nonprofit killer bill” that would allow the Treasury Secretary to declare any nonprofit a “terrorist-supporting organization” and strip its tax-exempt status without due process. Progressive media like Truthout that has courageously focused on reporting on Israel’s genocide in Gaza are in the bill’s crosshairs.
As journalists, we have a responsibility to look at hard realities and communicate them to you. We hope that you, like us, can use this information to prepare for what’s to come.
And if you feel uncertain about what to do in the face of a second Trump administration, we invite you to be an indispensable part of Truthout’s preparations.
In addition to covering the widespread onslaught of draconian policy, we’re shoring up our resources for what might come next for progressive media: bad-faith lawsuits from far-right ghouls, legislation that seeks to strip us of our ability to receive tax-deductible donations, and further throttling of our reach on social media platforms owned by Trump’s sycophants.
We’re preparing right now for Trump’s Day One: building a brave coalition of movement media; reaching out to the activists, academics, and thinkers we trust to shine a light on the inner workings of authoritarianism; and planning to use journalism as a tool to equip movements to protect the people, lands, and principles most vulnerable to Trump’s destruction.
We urgently need your help to prepare. As you know, our December fundraiser is our most important of the year and will determine the scale of work we’ll be able to do in 2025. We’ve set two goals: to raise $104,000 in one-time donations and to add 1340 new monthly donors by midnight on December 31.
Today, we’re asking all of our readers to start a monthly donation or make a one-time donation – as a commitment to stand with us on day one of Trump’s presidency, and every day after that, as we produce journalism that combats authoritarianism, censorship, injustice, and misinformation. You’re an essential part of our future – please join the movement by making a tax-deductible donation today.
If you have the means to make a substantial gift, please dig deep during this critical time!
With gratitude and resolve,
Maya, Negin, Saima, and Ziggy