One would be hard-pressed to find a more symbolic victory for clean energy than a solar farm taking up residence inside the former home of one of the largest coal-fired power plants in North America. That’s what is happening, on the shores of Lake Erie in Ontario, Canada.
Never miss another story
Get the news you want, delivered to your inbox every day.
At one time, the Nanticoke generating station was producing a staggering 4,000 megawatts of energy and was one of the country’s largest greenhouse gas emitters. The plant was officially decommissioned in 2013, part of a long process to shutter all coal-fired plants in the province — a goal that was accomplished in 2014.
Now, in a move that unites local First Nations business leaders and renewable energy companies, the mothballed site will soon be home to a solar farm called Nanticoke Solar. The new project is a joint venture of Sun Edison Canadian Construction and the Six Nations of the Grand River Development Corporation.
The facility — located in Haldimand County on four separate parcels of land including a former coal pile — is expected to generate 44 megawatts and utilize the transmission wires already in place. The plant’s capacity, is just a little over one percent of the some 4,000 megawatts the former coal plant used to generate, but it’s part of Ontario’s larger effort to replace coal with renewable energy sources.
Currently, the province of Ontario meets the majority of its energy needs through nuclear and hydroelectric generation. Clean energy sources — wind, solar and bioenergy — provide just six per cent of the province’s energy demand. Unlike most Canadian provinces, Ontario’s emissions are on the way down — already at six per cent below 1990 levels. The long-term goal of the province’s climate change strategy is an 80 per cent reduction in 1990 emission levels by 2050.
Nanticoke Solar is one of 16 new renewable energy projects announced by Ontario’s Independent Electricity System Operator that in total could generate 455.885 megawatts of renewable energy including five wind, seven solar and four hydroelectric contracts. Of the new projects announced, 13 involve participation from Aboriginal communities.
“Six Nations has been involved in renewable energy for quite some time,” says Matt Jamieson, the president and CEO of the Six Nations development corporation, an equity investor in the project. “We are a participant , through the (now defunct) Ontario Power Authority’s Feed-in Tariff Program and we gained a lot of exposure through our partnership with Samsung at the Grand River Energy Park. We’ve demonstrated the First Nations community capacity to get projects done, those that benefit the environment.”
In addition to generating clean energy, the project also manages to reuse an old industrial facility that has been nothing but a financial liability for the past two years.
“There are a tremendous amount of transmission lines essentially sitting idle and a quite expansive supply of land owned by OPG, so it made sense to work with them,” Jamieson says. “That was the real motivation for us; it made a lot of sense.”
In addition, the deal should also provide jobs for First Nations members. One of the corporations’ stated goals, according to Jamieson, is to “maximize employment of our community members.” The group has a contract to sell power back to the Ontario power grid at a set rate for 20 years. Beyond Nanticoke, the Six Nations group is looking for more ways to get involved in renewable energy.
“Our activities align with our cultural values,” Jamieson explains. “You won’t find us engaging in development activities that conflict with the environment or those elements that are important to us.”
Six Nations of the Grand River is the largest First Nations reserve in Canada, with more than 25,000 members. The corporation was set up after a long 18-month process of dialogue and discovery with the Six Nations of the Grand River.
“We take a multi-generational approach,” Jamieson says. “There is a common expression that asks to look to the next seven generations to make sure there is nothing well down the line [that will be negatively impacted by] what we are doing today. We are hypersensitive to this.”
Construction work for the project is set to begin in 2017 and the solar plant is expected to start operating by late 2018 or early 2019.
The project hasn’t been without its detractors though. Toby Barrett, a local conservative Member of Provincial Parliament, described Nanticoke Solar “a symbolic move” for province premier Kathleen Wynne. “It will be a good photo-op for Kathleen Wynne to let environmental extremists know that she has replaced the coal pile with solar panels. And when they get around to knocking down the stacks, that’ll be another photo-op,” he told a local newspaper.
Barrett pointed out that power produced by the former coal plant cost only 2 cents per kilowatt hour, while energy from the solar plant would cost consumers nearly eight times more, or about 15.67 cents a kilowatt hour.
But such criticism doesn’t take into account the long-term environmental and public health benefits of shifting away from coal. Here’s a small example: In 2015, the first full year when Ontario was entirely coal-fired power free, the province had zero smog days.