Skip to content Skip to footer

The Home of the Free Speech Movement Suppresses Freedom of Speech

The Beehive Collective and the No on Prop. 1 coalition are currently on a tour of California, Sucked Dry: Examining Drought and Privatization from Mesoamerica to California, to bring their arguments for a sustainable water future and against the water bond to Bay Area residents in an interactive events in the Bay Area.

In the home of the Free Speech Movement at the U.C. Berkeley campus, students got a rude awakening when what they describe as an administrator “with clear political motivations” shut down the Beehive Collective’s art project on drought and Proposition 1, Governor Jerry Brown’s $7.5 billion water bond.

This year marks the fiftieth anniversary of the Free Speech Movement. In the conclusion of Mario Savio’s class speech, before Free Speech Movement demonstrators entered Sproul Hall to begin their sit-in on December 3, 1964, the late Savio said:

“We have an autocracy which runs this university. It’s managed. We asked the following: if President Kerr actually tried to get something more liberal out of the Regents in his telephone conversation, why didn’t he make some public statement to that effect? And the answer we received — from a well-meaning liberal — was the following: He said, “Would you ever imagine the manager of a firm making a statement publicly in opposition to his board of directors?”

That’s the answer! Now, I ask you to consider: if this is a firm, and if the Board of Regents are the board of directors, and if President Kerr in fact is the manager, then I’ll tell you something: the faculty are a bunch of employees, and we’re the raw material! But we’re a bunch of raw material[s] that don’t mean to have any process upon us, don’t mean to be made into any product, don’t mean to end up being bought by some clients of the University, be they the government, be they industry, be they organized labor, be they anyone! We’re human beings!

There is a time when the operation of the machine becomes so odious, makes you so sick at heart, that you can’t take part; you can’t even passively take part, and you’ve got to put your bodies upon the gears and upon the wheels, upon the levers, upon all the apparatus, and you’ve got to make it stop. And you’ve got to indicate to the people who run it, to the people who own it, that unless you’re free, the machine will be prevented from working at all.”

These prophetic words become even more chilling and real 50 years later, after the passage of the Patriot Act, the NDAA, the coordinated, brutal suppression of the Occupy movement across the country, the militarization of the police and security forces, the NSA spying scandal and the increasing repression of freedom of speech and the Constitution under the presidency of a constitutional lawyer.

In a stand for the First Amendment, students at the University of California, Berkeley brought the Beehive Collective’s art project on drought and Prop. 1 on Tuesday, October 21, to the steps of Sproul Plaza, where 50 years ago students demonstrated for their right to disseminate political materials. From 2-5 pm, the Beehive Collective displayed their art and informally told the stories of their pieces to the gathered students.

“The event highlights the privatization of water across Mesoamerica and the potential for water privatization in CA under Prop 1 – and was originally scheduled as an event at the Gill Tract Community Farm,” according to a news release from Students for Engaged and Active Learning (SEAL). “This community farm was won through Occupy the Farm’s acts of civil disobedience protesting the privatization of this land, and is now the site of a partnership project between the community and the College of Natural Resources at UC Berkeley.”

The students said the event was shut down with a week’s notice by Steve Lindow, the first researcher to do field trials of a Genetically Modified Organism (GMOs), who is now the Executive Associate Dean in the College of Natural Resources.

Lindow claimed that the art show was “not relevant to the research at the community farm,” despite clear connections between the Beehive Collective’s work on drought and industrial agriculture, the students reported. Water bond opponents have criticized Prop. 1 as a sweetheart bill for water-intensive industrial agriculture.

The students said the event had been approved with strong support from community members, students, and the farm’s events working group. This was the first interference in farm events from the administration – and students feel that it is a clear example of repression against free speech on campus, with political motivation.

“We were there Tuesday because the administration shut down the event about the privatization of a natural resource, water, at the site of resistance against the privatization of land,” said Paula Jaramillo of Students for Engaged and Active Learning (SEAL). “We were shut down by someone who actively privatizes life itself through patenting GMOs.”

“Prop. 1 is known as a sweetheart initiative for Big Ag and the event was supposed to take place at Gill Tract, where we are seeking to find sustainable alternatives to industrial agriculture, and it was a perfect site to have this event. It was a shame the administration denied the students this opportunity – and it was complete repression of freedom of speech because of a political motivation,” Jaramillo explained.

“The Beehive Collective, named after an important pollinator, is of absolute relevance to the research of the Gill Tract Community Farm,” confirmed Sakura Saunders, Beehive Collective Member. “The Beehive Collective, which has a long history of creating art work that represents the negative ecological impacts of GMO crops and monocultures, was set to present on a topic relevant to all farmers within California: water.”

“Specifically, the group aimed to bring a critical perspective on a water infrastructure bond, Prop. 1, which will appear on Californian’s ballots in the upcoming election. It is a shame that this timely and politically-relevant talk could not go forward as scheduled, even after posters were distributed listing the Gill Tract Farm as the venue,” she emphasized.

I have left a phone message at the office of Steve Lindow, Professor and Executive Associate Dean, College of Natural Resources, and I’m waiting for his response.

Students for Engaged and Active Learning, Fossil Free Cal, and Students Against Fracking supported the event. The event at the Gill Tract had also received the support of Food and Water Watch, a national consumer group that has endorsed NO on Prop 1.

More about the Beehive Collective “Sucked Dry” Storytelling:

California is in the midst of a historical drought, the most severe the region has had in the last 500 years. This water crisis has devastated resources, with several communities facing the prospect of running dry. A number of projects advocating infrastructure development such as the BDCP and Prop 1 have been proposed as solutions for the state, but are they truly in the interests for all? What are their impacts to our drying rivers and reservoirs? Fisheries and communities?

Drawing inspiration from struggles against large-scale infrastructure projects throughout MesoAmerica, the Beehive collective’s larger than life art pieces are engaging lessons in political education. This informal storytelling event will guide students on a visual journey touching on the local and the global struggle for control and protection of water.

The Beehive Collective and the No on Prop. 1 coalition are currently on a tour of California, Sucked Dry: Examining Drought and Privatization from Mesoamérica to California, to bring their arguments for a sustainable water future and against the water bond to Bay Area residents in an interactive events in the Bay Area.

“Prop. 1 is one more shovel of dirt on the grave of our salmon, crab and other Pacific fisheries,” said Javier Padilla-Reyes, No on Prop. 1 field representative. “Building more dams to hold water we don’t have is misplaced spending and harms the businesses, families and communities that depend upon our salmon, crab and other fisheries.”

Beehive Collective’s Ryan Camero said, “Our graphics are a great way to spark conversations about complex matters like the current water politics of California.”

The Beehive Design Collective is an all-volunteer organization of activists, artists, educators and organizers. Their main focus is creating and presenting graphic works about global issues.

For more information: go to

Schedule of “Sucked Dry” Events

October 23- Santa Cruz
Museum of Art and History w/ UC Santa Cruz
705 Front St. Santa Cruz CA 95060

October 24- SLO (San Luis Obispo)
Linneas Cafe
1110 Garden St. San Luis Obispo CA 93401

October 25- Santa Barbara (TBA)

October 26- Los Angeles
Hollenbeck Park in Boyle Heights w/ Food and Water Watch (Daytime)
415 S. St. Louis St. Los Angeles CA 90033

October 27- Ventura
The Lab (Nighttime)
11137 Azahar St Ventura CA 93003

October 28- San Bernardino
Black Flame Collective (Nighttime)
360 W. Orange Show Ln. San Bernardino CA 92408

October 29- Bakersfield (TBA)

October 30- Fresno
Anvil Art Gallery/Manchester Experiment
3302 Blackstone Ave Suite G 203 Fresno CA 93726

October 31- Davis
Delta of Venus Cafe
122 B St. Davis CA 95616
Starting at 1pm

November 1- Redding (TBA)

November 2- Sacramento (TBA)

November 3- Stockton
Huddle w/ With Our Words, DeltaFusion, Restore the Delta and others
235 N San Joaquin St. Stockton, CA 95202

November 4 – Sacramento
Sol Collective
2574 21st St. Sacramento CA 95818

Join us in defending the truth before it’s too late

The future of independent journalism is uncertain, and the consequences of losing it are too grave to ignore. To ensure Truthout remains safe, strong, and free, we need to raise $34,000 in the next 72 hours. Every dollar raised goes directly toward the costs of producing news you can trust.

Please give what you can — because by supporting us with a tax-deductible donation, you’re not just preserving a source of news, you’re helping to safeguard what’s left of our democracy.