Did you know that Truthout is a nonprofit and independently funded by readers like you? If you value what we do, please support our work with a donation.
Israel has a large, sophisticated and undeclared nuclear arsenal, but Prime Minister Netanyahu told scary stories to a rapt US Congress entranced by his warnings about the chance that Iran might consider building one bomb a decade from now, a double standard if there ever was one.
One of the strangest aspects of the frantic crying of alarm over Iranβs nuclear program β with the crying having reached its most publicized peak in Benjamin Netanyahuβs Republican/Likud campaign rally in the House chamber β is that the chief crier is the government of a country that not only has the most advanced nuclear program in the Middle East but has kept that program completely out of the reach and scrutiny of any international control and inspection regime.
It is hard to think of a better example in international politics of the pot calling the kettle black, and in this case the pot is much blacker than the kettle β and was so even before Iran put its program under the unprecedented restrictions and intrusive inspections to which it agreed more than a year ago in negotiations with the United States and the rest of the P5+1.
As for any military dimensions (the focus, of course, of all that crying when it comes to Iran), although neither Israel nor the United States says publicly that Israel has nuclear weapons, just about everyone else on the planet who says anything on the subject takes it as a given that it does, and that it has a fairly sizable arsenal of such weapons.
The person outside government who has studied the Israeli nuclear program most extensively is Avner Cohen, an Israeli-born scholar currently based in the United States. Cohen has written two books on the subject, Israel and the Bomb and The Worst-Kept Secret: Israelβs Bargain with the Bomb. He probably knows more than anyone outside the Israeli government about the Israeli program and the strategic thinking underlying it.
It thus is especially interesting to hear what Cohen has to say about the current battle over the Iranian program. In a commentary just published in the Israeli newspaper Haaretz, Cohen writes about how, as I discussed the other day, the actions and lobbying of Benjamin Netanyahu are at odds with his own alarmist rhetoric, and about what this implies concerning Netanyahuβs motivations.
Cohen criticizes Netanyahuβs drumbeat message that the agreement being negotiated would be very bad for Israel; he notes the βpotential advantagesβ of the agreement, which is from the standpoint of Israelβs interests a βreasonable compromise.β He points out that the demand to prevent any Iranian enrichment of uranium will never be realized, and that the demand has no basis in the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty.
Cohen goes on to state that the emerging agreement
βalso contains unique advantages barely discussed in Israel. It clearly distances Iran from a nuclear bomb β from a few weeks as was the case in 2012 to about a year. Most importantly, it establishes a regime of safeguards and transparency for almost a generation.β
Cohen concludes by pointedly describing what Netanyahuβs scaremongering efforts are really all about, which have to do with Netanyahu having made such alarmism his political signature music, on which he relies both to maintain political power in Israel and to rationalize his policies to the outside world:
βDespite its flaws, the proposed agreement is far from bad for Israel β the only nuclear power in the Middle East β but it is very bad for Netanyahu. The agreement offers Israel almost a generation, or even more if it succeeds, in which Netanyahu wonβt be able to sow fear about Iran as an existential danger. It would leave Netanyahu as a leader whose raison dβΓͺtre has been taken away from him.β
Netanyahuβs narrowly-motivated efforts to destroy the diplomacy with Iran are not only directly contrary to U.S. interests; they also are contrary to Israelβs interests. Those who really do care about Israel and its security, rather than just ritualistically referring to them while swaying and bobbing up and down to Netanyahuβs music, need to realize that.
Press freedom is under attack
As Trump cracks down on political speech, independent media is increasingly necessary.
Truthout produces reporting you wonβt see in the mainstream: journalism from the frontlines of global conflict, interviews with grassroots movement leaders, high-quality legal analysis and more.
Our work is possible thanks to reader support. Help Truthout catalyze change and social justice β make a tax-deductible monthly or one-time donation today.