Critics Slam Columbia’s Capitulation to Trump in $200M Deal to Restore Grants

Columbia University has agreed to pay a $200 million fine and make other significant concessions to the Trump administration in a deal to restore federal grants canceled earlier this year as part of the president’s assault on institutions of higher education.

Under the terms of the settlement, which was released Wednesday, Columbia agreed to “conduct a thorough review” of its educational programs “in regional areas across the university, starting with the Middle East” — bowing to the Trump administration’s interference in curriculum-related decisions.

Columbia also pledged to “undertake a comprehensive review of its international admissions processes” and “ensure that international student-applicants are asked questions to elicit their reasons for wishing to study in the United States” as the Trump administration — under the guise of combating antisemitism — targets international students who have taken part in Palestinian rights demonstrations.

Earlier this week, Columbia suspended or expelled dozens of students over Gaza-related protests.

Columbia’s deal with the federal government sparked immediate, furious backlash, with critics condemning the university’s leaders as “cowards” who are “bowing down to authoritarianism.”

Rep. Jerry Nadler (D-N.Y.), whose district includes Columbia, said he was “deeply disappointed” to learn of the university’s “outrageous and embarrassing $200 million capitulation to the Trump administration’s repugnant extortion campaign.”

In response to the Trump administration’s claim that the university was violating federal law by failing to protect its Jewish students, Nadler stressed that “no investigation was ever conducted by the Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights — the single body charged under federal law with investigating antisemitism on campus.” (Columbia did not admit to wrongdoing as part of the agreement.)

“Rather, unlike Harvard, my alma mater has allowed a once highly respected institution to succumb to the Trump administration’s coercive and exploitative tactics,” Nadler said in a statement. “Columbia has effectively waived the white flag of surrender in its battle at the heart of the Trump administration’s war on higher education and academic freedom.”

The Columbia Daily Spectator, the university’s student newspaper, reported that under its settlement with the Trump administration, the university “agreed to reveal the admissions data of both rejected and admitted students, including their race, GPA, and standardized test performance, to the federal government.”

“As part of the deal, the federal government will not institute ‘any civil action’ against the university and will resume canceled National Institutes of Health and Health and Human Services funding, but does not restore grants from the Department of Education,” the Spectator observed. “The university is required to comply with Title VI to maintain the terms of the deal.”

‪Jacob Schriner-Briggs‬, visiting assistant professor at the Chicago-Kent College of Law, wrote on social media that the deal represents “a vicious blow to the academic freedom of university employees and students alike” and accused Columbia of “taking its lead from the government as to what questions it will ask international applicants and which ‘longstanding traditions’ it will ensure all of its students are ‘committed to.'”

“This capitulation is indefensible,” wrote Schriner-Briggs.