Truthout is a vital news source and a living history of political struggle. If you think our work is valuable, support us with a donation of any size.
On Tuesday, a federal appellate court ruled that an injunction barring the enforcement of Florida’s drag show ban could remain in place pending the outcome of the case in lower courts, finding that the ban is likely in violation of First Amendment speech freedoms.
The Florida law, passed by a Republican state legislature and signed by GOP Gov. Ron DeSantis, doesn’t explicitly mention drag shows in its text. But the regulation of “adult live performances” in front of audiences with children present — including shows that use “prosthetic or imitation genitals or breasts” — undoubtedly targets drag shows. Venues that violate the statute face fines and the possibility of having their liquor license suspended or revoked, while individuals could be charged with a misdemeanor.
The law was challenged by Hamburger Mary’s restaurant in Orlando, Florida, which regularly hosts family-friendly drag shows for its patrons.
In a 2-1 decision before the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals, the court’s majority ruling, authored by Judge Robin Rosenbaum, found that the law was not specific enough in detailing what should be regulated, adding that the plaintiffs had a very high likelihood of success in showing their First Amendment speech rights would be violated by enforcement of the law.
“By providing only vague guidance as to which performances it prohibits, the Act wields a shotgun when the First Amendment allows a scalpel at most,” Rosenbaum wrote in the court’s opinion.
The provisions of the law “turn the Act into an ‘I know it when I see it’ law,” Rosenbaum added. “But the Constitution requires more clarity.”
Although the law itself never mentions drag show performances, those involved in its passage — including DeSantis and one of the bill’s legislative cosponsors — directly alluded to targeting drag shows.
The court recognized this fact in its opinion.
“Though the Act applies to a range of ‘adult live performances, its enactors focused on how it would restrict one particular type of performance: drag shows,” Rosenbaum wrote.
The court upheld the injunction placed on the law by a judge in a lower court, where the case will now move forward for an eventual final judgment.
Brian Wright, a spokesperson within DeSantis’s office, decried the ruling.
“No one has a constitutional right to perform sexual routines in front of little kids. We will do everything possible to have this lawless decision overturned,” Wright said.
But Hamburger Mary’s co-owner John Paonessa noted that the governor’s definition of what is “sexual” is far too ambiguous.
“For them, lewd and inappropriate is just a drag queen dressed in clothes not exposing anything. That, to them, is too much,” Paonessa said.
“The Court’s opinion recognizes this law for what it is — an egregiously unconstitutional attempt to censor the speech and expression of citizens,” said Melissa Stewart, the attorney representing Hamburger Mary’s in the lawsuit.
A terrifying moment. We appeal for your support.
In the last weeks, we have witnessed an authoritarian assault on communities in Minnesota and across the nation.
The need for truthful, grassroots reporting is urgent at this cataclysmic historical moment. Yet, Trump-aligned billionaires and other allies have taken over many legacy media outlets — the culmination of a decades-long campaign to place control of the narrative into the hands of the political right.
We refuse to let Trump’s blatant propaganda machine go unchecked. Untethered to corporate ownership or advertisers, Truthout remains fearless in our reporting and our determination to use journalism as a tool for justice.
But we need your help just to fund our basic expenses. Over 80 percent of Truthout’s funding comes from small individual donations from our community of readers, and over a third of our total budget is supported by recurring monthly donors.
Truthout’s fundraiser ended last night, and we fell just short of our goal. But your support still matters immensely. Whether you can make a small monthly donation or a larger one-time gift, Truthout only works with your help.