Skip to content Skip to footer

A Call for a Justice and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa

We call again for such a commission in light of the reality that most of the universities in South Africa have shut down.

In 2008, in response to what were called the “xenophobic riots” in the townships, we argued that only complete reform of the economy can provide solutions to the despair and desperation of the majority black population who have been living in horrific poverty.

At that time, we called for a Justice and Reconciliation Commission, which Professor Mahmood Mamdani and myself [Sampie Terreblanche], had already argued in 1998 was absolutely necessary for a full review of the supply-side capitalist economics that had already come to dominate the economic policy in South Africa.

In 2016, we call again for such a commission in light of the devastating reality that most of the universities in South Africa have shut down because there has been no creative and thoughtful solution to demands of the students for fee reduction in education.

But we would take this demand one step further and argue and defend the right to free public higher education. The question of free public higher education is not only one for South Africa but is one that needs to be addressed worldwide. Free public educational is not some crazy utopian fantasy. It is simply one that demands the rethinking of fiscal priorities that would lead South Africa out of its current state of being as a post-colonial satellite of the United States-led global empire and its triumphalist vision of neoliberal capitalism.

We support the students not only in their demand for free education but for free higher public education as a right that should be defended by the constitution and the ethic of ubuntu.

Let’s look at some of the facts. Between 2000 and 2013, government grants to universities dropped from 50% of their income to 40%. Between 2000 and 2013, student numbers rose by 80% from 560000 to 980000. The government spent only 0.7% of the GDP on universities.

Releasing the 2015 higher education statistics on the October 24, the statistician-general, Dr Pali Lehohlo said among the priorities South Africa had set itself since 1994, education ranked number 18.

South African universities (particularly historically black institutions) are over-crowded. While they only have an enrolment capacity of 600000 students, these universities have however enrolled about a million students, resulting in terrible learning and teaching conditions, lack of necessary resources and facilities capable of producing high quality teaching and learning, poor pay forfaculty, insufficient teaching staff, low morale among faculty and ultimately a serious compromise of quality. In short, the university system in South Africa, according to Lehohlo, is inefficient.

The level of university education among the black majority is presently lower than was the case in 1994. The fragility of black student lives and righteous protest that it has inspired needs to be taken very seriously notwithstanding the recent increase in budget allocations.

But, as we said in 2008, and we will say it again, the crisis of the university can only be seen as the result of the capitulation of the supply-side capitalist economics which is completely inadequate for the project of decolonisation and economic justice. Students are being jailed with trumped-up charges. The universities have been militarised. And all too horribly, black students are being racially profiled and kept out of university buildings — crucially library access.

The online solution which many universities have adopted, which is to provide education only through the internet so students will only have access to the campus through the internet, is not only shortsighted but also fails to grapple with the problem which is the gross resource and income inequality of the students in South Africa.

Many students do not have internet facilities in their homes or their townships and would have to travel miles to access and pay fees at internet cafes. Many black students rely on access to the library in order to be able to connect to the internet.

But the problem of universities, and let us say it again, cannot be resolved until the structure of the economy is finally put up for political and ethical discussion. In order to do that, we need a Justice and Reconciliation Commission.

As we have said before, the aim of such a commission is to focus on the systematic character of racial capitalism, which began long before the institutionalisation of apartheid.

A crucial aspect of this commission would be to return to programmes such as advocated by one of the authors [Terreblanche] who proposed a wealth tax to the Truth and Reconciliation Commissionin 1997. The proposal was aimed at raising billions of rand for a comprehensive redistributive justice programme towards eradicating apartheid inequalities, including education backlogs.

At the time that he made this suggestion, he was ridiculed as an out of date leftist. But his proposals have never been more necessary and had they been adopted there would not be the desperate cycle of education and poverty crises that we see today.

The statistician-general has, in the midst of student protest, recently reiterated the call [by Terreblanche] for greater prioritisation of education as a necessary solution to the country’s higher education crisis.

We completely disagree with statements that we have to choose between higher education andprimary and secondary education. What we need to do is finally have a democratic discussion about what kind of economy the people of this country need and deserve.

Once again, we call for a two year commission which would explore alternatives to the current Anglo-Americanisiton of the South African economy which has effectively blocked transformation.

We of course, given the current crisis, would focus on education and how to develop acomprehensive education policy. The commission would work with community organisations that have sought to develop programmes of restitution and reparation that must be seriously considered as part of a democratic discussion of economic reform.

Consultation with economists who are exploring alternatives to capitalism would also be vital.

The outcome of the commission would be a comprehensive programme of reform of all basic areas of life: education, housing, health, land reform, and the organisation of production.

With a different set of economic priories we believe a demand for free higher education is perfectly reasonable, but more importantly at this point we need to have an open and democratic discussion of the economy and we need to build an institution that would facilitate that.

So we repeat our call for a Justice and Reconciliation Commission which would allow us to address the horrific injustice undermining every aspect of life in South Africa.

Urgent message, before you scroll away

You may not know that Truthout’s journalism is funded overwhelmingly by individual supporters. Readers just like you ensure that unique stories like the one above make it to print – all from an uncompromised, independent perspective.

At this very moment, we’re conducting a fundraiser with a goal to raise $26,000 in the next 24 hours. So, if you’ve found value in what you read today, please consider a tax-deductible donation in any size to ensure this work continues. We thank you kindly for your support.