Skip to content Skip to footer

Progressives Urge Dems to Call House Minority Leader to Testify at Trump Trial

Some say the failure to call witnesses after news of Trump’s remarks to Kevin McCarthy would be a dereliction of duty.

Donald Trump speaks as he is joined by Rep. Kevin McCarthy (R-California) in the Rose Garden of the White House on January 4, 2019, in Washington, D.C.

Democratic House impeachment managers are facing growing public pressure to call witnesses to testify at Donald Trump’s Senate impeachment trial in the wake of bombshell reporting on the former president’s conversation with Republican House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy during the January 6 assault on the U.S. Capitol by a right-wing mob.

Progressive watchdog groups, as Common Dreams reported earlier this week, have been urging Democrats to call witnesses since before the start of the trial, but CNN’s late Friday story on Trump’s conversation with McCarthy added fuel to those demands.

During the phone call, according to CNN, Trump told the California Republican, “Well, Kevin, I guess these people are more upset about the election than you are,” a comment that reportedly prompted a shouting match between the two GOP leaders as McCarthy pleaded with the then-president to speak out against the attack.

While the Democratic leadership is hoping for a speedy end to the trial in order to move forward with confirmation of President Joe Biden’s nominees and legislative business — including coronavirus relief — critics argued Friday night that failure to call witnesses following news of Trump’s remarks to McCarthy would be a dereliction of duty.

“Democrats should call Kevin McCarthy as a witness and have him testify under oath about this call,” tweeted Judd Legum, author of the Popular Information newsletter. “I know they want to wrap this up but it won’t take long. The American people deserve the truth.”

After House impeachment managers, led by Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Maryland), delivered their striking case on Wednesday in support of convicting the former president for inciting a deadly insurrection against the U.S. government, several members of the Senate Democratic caucus said Thursday that witnesses would not be necessary.

“I feel like we’ve heard from enough witnesses,” said Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-New York), referring to interviews played during House Democrats’ presentation. Sen. Angus King (I-Maine), who caucuses with Democrats, “I think the case has been made. I don’t know what witnesses would add.”

But observers argued that the new details of Trump’s phone conversation with McCarthy indicate that compelling the House Republican leader and others to testify under oath could yield important new information. Calling witnesses would require a simple-majority vote in the Senate.

“As evidence of Trump’s behind-the-scenes sociopathy mounts, it becomes clearer that Dems must call witnesses,” said The Washington Post’s Greg Sargent.

Others echoed that sentiment, pointing also to new reporting confirming that Trump was aware that former Vice President Mike Pence was in danger when he tweeted an attack on Pence during the mob assault.

In an appearance on MSNBC late Friday, Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Maryland) argued the new reporting “undermines the entire defense that the president’s lawyers have put on” and said he would be open to calling witnesses to testify at the trial.

“I think [House impeachment managers] have established a slam-dunk case that the president incited violence for the purpose of overturning the election,” said Van Hollen. “If they make a decision to call witnesses… obviously we would welcome that.”

Watch:

What happens next?

Only a few days remain before the presidential election. To make sure we can continue our vital coverage before Tuesday, we’re asking for your support.

Truthout is funded overwhelmingly by readers like you. Your gift allows us to hold the political candidates accountable, delve into the nuance of complex issues, and stay wholly focused on seeking justice.

No matter what happens on November 5, your gift today ensures that there’s a place for independent journalism in the future – regardless of right-wing suppression, industry corporatization, and any other challenges we have yet to face. Please make a one-time or monthly donation to Truthout today.