Did you know that Truthout is a nonprofit and independently funded by readers like you? If you value what we do, please support our work with a donation.
Americans have expressed doubts that the GOP’s tax plan would benefit them in a meaningful way — even if they’re in the segment of the population that could receive $1,182 more per year in tax savings — especially compared to the huge tax cut given to corporations under the plan. (Photo: Pixabay)
Appearing on CNN Thursday, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) argued that the $1,182 that Republicans spent the day touting as the money average American families will save under their tax plan, is far from what the government could afford to give them — if they weren’t spending that money on massive tax cuts for the rich.
Elizabeth Warren: This isn’t about middle class, it’s about helping big GOP donors and putting “a pretty face on it” https://t.co/1Dk7VeVmhv
— CNN (@CNN) November 2, 2017
As House Leader Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) and his colleagues said in a press conference unveiling some of the proposal’s details, “the typical family of four will save $1,182 a year on their taxes.”
Get our free emails
Most American families would happily accept an extra $1200 per year to help with bills, college funds, and savings — but the estimated sum of $1,182 will only apply to families of four earning $59,000 per year, not lower income households.
Critics were also concerned about the GOP’s plans for the Child Tax Credit. As the CBPP explained in September after the Republicans unveiled the framework for their plan, the Party “proposed to make their Child Tax Credit increase non-refundable, meaning that working families with incomes too low to have federal income tax liability would not benefit.” A single parent raising two children making minimum wage would be left out of receiving the credit.
Sister Simone Campbell of NETWORK Lobby for Catholic Social Justice also noted that immigrant families would lose out under the plan. The so-called Tax Cuts & Jobs Act “rips the credits away from 5.1 million children whose parents are immigrant taxpayers with an average annual income of $21,000, which is a loss of 8.5% of their annual income. This will directly jeopardize the economic, educational, and developmental outcomes of children living in the U.S.”
On social media, Americans expressed doubts that the GOP’s tax plan would benefit them in a meaningful way — even if they’re in the segment of the population that could receive $1,182 more per year in tax savings — especially compared to the huge tax cut given to corporations under the plan.
All #1182more is, is 1.5 months of my student loan payments. So thanks for basically nothing @gop.
— Bre Witmer (@bre518) November 2, 2017
The @GOP Tax plan translates to $22.73 in savings per week. Which is enough to fill the family minivan’s gas tank 1/2 to full. #1182more
— Brianna Westbrook (@BWestbrookAZ8) November 2, 2017
The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act must be a joke. $1200 will barely cover monthly insurance costs for a family of 4. #1182more
— Matt K (@dcdaddysWT) November 2, 2017
whoohoo! Where do I start spending this $22.73 a week? (so worth saddling my children & grand children with massive&growing federal deficit)
— Brian Lyman (@BDLyman) November 2, 2017
Urgent appeal for your support: Help us fight political repression.
Truthout urgently appeals for your support. Under pressure from an array of McCarthyist anti-speech tactics, independent journalists at Truthout face new and mounting political repression.
We rely on your support to publish movement journalism — in fact, we’re almost entirely funded by readers like you. Yet, donations are down at this moment of crisis. We may end this month in the red without additional help, so we’ve launched a fundraiser.
We have 8 days to hit our $46,000 goal. Please contribute a tax-deductible gift to Truthout at this critical moment.