A federal judge in Virginia dealt the first major legal blow against the Obama administration’s health care reform law on Monday, setting the stage for a final showdown over mandatory health insurance in the Supreme Court.
District Judge Henry Hudson issued a 42-page ruling that declared the law’s individual mandate clause that would require Americans to purchase health insurance or pay a penalty to be unconstitutional.
Hudson decided not to issue an injunction to block implementation of health care reform because the clause in question will not go into effect until 2013, and the federal government should honor his judgment alone until the decision is appealed.
“And the final word will undoubtedly rest in a higher court,” Hudson wrote, indicating that the Supreme Court will have the final say on the issue.
The Obama administration has indicated that the ruling will not hamper the implementation of other aspects of health care reform.
The case is the most prominent among a number of legal challenges filed in several states since federal health care reform passed in March. Oral arguments on the constitutionality of health care reform will be heard in Florida on Thursday as the result of lawsuits filed by 20 states against the federal government.
The ruling is a big victory for conservatives and Republican Virginia Attorney General Ken Cucinelli, who was able to make a case against the federal government after the Virginia legislature passed a new law this year making it illegal to make health insurance mandatory for Virginians.
“It is unconstitutional because the federal government is claiming that the source of its power for imposing the mandate is the Constitution’s Commerce Clause, which gives the federal government the power to ‘regulate commerce among the several states…,'” Cucinelli explains in his media blog. “We argue that if someone isn’t buying insurance, then – by definition – he is not participating in commerce.”
Our most important fundraising appeal of the year
December is the most critical time of year for Truthout, because our nonprofit news is funded almost entirely by individual donations from readers like you. So before you navigate away, we ask that you take just a second to support Truthout with a tax-deductible donation.
This year is a little different. We are up against a far-reaching, wide-scale attack on press freedom coming from the Trump administration. 2025 was a year of frightening censorship, news industry corporate consolidation, and worsening financial conditions for progressive nonprofits across the board.
We can only resist Trump’s agenda by cultivating a strong base of support. The right-wing mediasphere is funded comfortably by billionaire owners and venture capitalist philanthropists. At Truthout, we have you.
We’ve set an ambitious target for our year-end campaign — a goal of $250,000 to keep up our fight against authoritarianism in 2026. Please take a meaningful action in this fight: make a one-time or monthly donation to Truthout before December 31. If you have the means, please dig deep.