Skip to content Skip to footer

Dr. Blasey Ford’s High School Alums Demand FBI Investigate Kavanaugh

Holton-Arms School alumna Alexis Goldstein discusses how survivors’ voices should be heard.

Dr. Christine Blasey Ford has agreed to testify before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Thursday about her allegations that Kavanaugh attempted to rape her when she was 15 years old and he was 17 years old. More than 1,100 alumnae of the Holton-Arms School, the Maryland prep school that Blasey Ford graduated from in 1984, have signed a letter in support of her sexual assault claims against Kavanaugh, saying they are grateful that she came forward to tell her story. In a letter, they wrote, “It demands a thorough and independent investigation before the Senate can reasonably vote on Brett Kavanaugh’s nomination to a lifetime seat on the nation’s highest court. Dr. Blasey Ford’s experience is all too consistent with stories we heard and lived while attending Holton. Many of us are survivors ourselves.” We speak with Holton-Arms School alumna Alexis Goldstein in Washington, DC. She helped organize the letter campaign in support of Blasey Ford.


AMY GOODMAN: This is Democracy Now!,, The War and Peace Report. I’m Amy Goodman, as we continue with the allegations against Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh as a second woman has come forward accusing him of sexual misconduct — Deborah Ramirez accusing Kavanaugh of exposing himself and thrusting his penis in her face during a college party in a Yale dorm room while they were both students at Yale. Ramirez speaking on the record to The New Yorker magazine in a piece that was just revealed last night, a piece by Jane Mayer and Ronan Farrow. Ramirez is now calling on the FBI to investigate her accusations.

This comes as Dr. Christine Blasey Ford has agreed to testify before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Thursday, 10:00 a.m. Eastern time, about her allegations that Kavanaugh attempted to rape her when she was 15 and he 17 years old. More than 1,100 alumni of the Holton-Arms School, the Maryland prep school that Blasey Ford graduated from in 1984, have signed a letter in support of her sexual assault claims against President Trump’s Supreme Court nominee, Judge Brett Kavanaugh, saying that they are grateful that she came forward to tell her story.

In the letter, they write, “It demands a thorough and independent investigation before the Senate can reasonably vote on Brett Kavanaugh’s nomination to a lifetime seat on the nation’s highest court. Dr. Blasey Ford’s experience is all too consistent with stories we heard and lived while attending Holton. Many of us are survivors ourselves,” they write. They delivered the letter last week to Republican Senator Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia, who also graduated from the Holton-Arms School.

For more, we’re joined in Washington, DC, by Alexis Goldstein, one of the Holton-Arms School alum who helped organize this letter campaign to support Christine Blasey Ford. Welcome to Democracy Now! It’s great to have you with us, Alexis. I know that you are racing off to the Supreme Court. Tell us about this letter that you spearheaded.

ALEXIS GOLDSTEIN: It was a group of six women who attended Holton-Arms, the class of 2005. Five of them wrote the text of the letter very quickly. I was very impressed with them. And we as the Holton-Arms community — a large, large number of us really wanted to say that we stood with Dr. Christine Blasey Ford and that we recognize her bravery in coming forward. This is coming at great personal cost to her. As folks have seen reported, she has been forced to move out of her home. She’s facing death threats. And I think those of us in the Holton-Arms community who signed this letter really just wanted to say, “Dr. Blasey Ford, we have your back, and we stand with you, and we believe you, and we know how incredibly difficult this is, and you are so brave and we are here for you.”

AMY GOODMAN: And explain what you’re referring to in this letter when you talk about Holton-Arms and the atmosphere at the time. Again, Judge Kavanaugh attended Georgetown Prep, which was a male prep school nearby.

ALEXIS GOLDSTEIN: I think what Dr. Blasey Ford describes resonates a lot with the Holton-Arms community, but it’s not just about the Holton-Arms community. I think pretty much any woman in America, this probably resonates with them. With any person in America. Whether you’re a survivor yourself, you probably know one, whether you know it or not. Sexual assault knows no political party. It’s not just something that happens at prep schools. It happens everywhere. But just like anywhere else or any other school, members of the Holton-Arms community, some of us, unfortunately, are familiar with this, and so we know how difficult it is to come forward. We know how much bravery it took her. And so we really just wanted to stand with her to say “Don’t mess with her” and that we have her back.

AMY GOODMAN: Now Alexis, there was another letter that was just her graduating class — Christine Blasey’s graduating class of 1984?

ALEXIS GOLDSTEIN: That’s right. The class of 1984 did their own separate letter. I believe there were 24 signers the last time I checked, but there might have been more since then. We linked to their letter on the website for our letter, which is They did it independently, but we just asked permission to link to their letter.

AMY GOODMAN: How did you deliver the letter to Congressmember Capito, who also went to your school? She is also an alum of Holton-Arms.

ALEXIS GOLDSTEIN: We wanted to make sure every alumna knew about this letter. That we wanted to give everyone an opportunity to sign. Julia Louis-Dreyfus is another alumna of Holton-Arms who we invited to sign. She did sign. Christine Lagarde is an alumna of Holton-Arms. We continue to invite her to sign. And Senator Capito is an alumna of Holton-Arms, and we just wanted to make absolutely sure that she saw the letter and had an invitation to sign it. So we went to her office last Thursday and hand-delivered a letter to the front desk. Senator Capito was not in the office at the time, but we just encouraged her staff to pass it along, and if she or her staff would like to meet with us in the future to just hear our invitation personally, we would be happy to do that. But we just wanted to make absolutely sure that Senator Capito know about the existence of the letter, and invite her, like we invite every Holton-Arms alumna, to consider signing.

AMY GOODMAN: Sorry — _Senator_ Capito — that’s right. And has Senator Capito — what did she do with the letter and has she responded to you all since? You are sister alum, after all.

ALEXIS GOLDSTEIN: I don’t know what the senator has done with the letter, but we have been in communication briefly with her staff. so at least one member of her staff knows — and the front desk, they’re aware of the letter — but we have not spoken to the Senator.

AMY GOODMAN: And why are you heading right away to the Supreme Court? Explain what is happening today in the United States.

ALEXIS GOLDSTEIN: I think this is a moment to say that this is not 1991, and that survivors must be heard and they must be believed. And I just want to be there on the steps of the Supreme Court today personally to show my support for Dr. Blasey Ford and say that we have her back, to say that we have the back of all survivors. I think that this is an opportunity to do one better than what happened with the Anita Hill hearings in 1991, although as was unfortunately mentioned earlier in your previous segment, there has not been an FBI investigation.

That is one of the things that our letter calls for, is for there to be in FBI investigation. The Holton-Arms alumni community wanted to echo Dr. Blasey Ford’s call for an investigation. And I think that is something that the Senate should do. So I just personally wanted to be there on the steps of the Supreme Court this morning to continue to stem with Dr. Blasey Ford and echo her call for an investigation.

AMY GOODMAN: And Alexis, your response to Senator Dianne Feinstein now calling for a hold on the confirmation proceedings of Judge Kavanaugh with the second person coming forward? Now Michael Avenatti, the lawyer for Stormy Daniels, is alleging that there may be a third woman who will be coming forward.

ALEXIS GOLDSTEIN: In our letter, we have always called for a thorough and independent investigation and now, just as before, is as good of a time as any to do it. It seems right to me personally that we should slow down. There is no rush here. Let’s do an investigation and let’s air all of these stories and let’s let all of these survivors be heard and be believed.

AMY GOODMAN: A lot is being talked about, about the atmosphere of these schools. We know about Mark Judge, who Dr. Christine Ford wanted to testify. She alleges he was the third person in the room at the time that she says that Kavanaugh attempted to rape her. And it was only when Judge jumped on top of the two of them and they tumbled to the floor that she was able to escape from underneath Kavanaugh, as she said he was holding her mouth, trying to prevent her from screaming — Kavanaugh was — and she was able to escape. But this book that he wrote about his high school years, about Georgetown Prep, that’s called _Wasted: Tales of a GenX Drunk,” the atmosphere they’re describing. And then what we hear Deborah Ramirez in the latest New Yorker piece allege what happened to her not so long after, when Kavanaugh was 18 at Yale. Talk more about that.

ALEXIS GOLDSTEIN: I don’t think any of this is unique to any one individual school. It’s certainly not unique to Holton-Arms. I can’t really speak to Yale; I was not a student at Yale. But I think unfortunately, sexual assault happens everywhere, and it’s an issue that is deeply personal for a lot of folks. It’s an issue that deserves serious consideration and to be taken seriously. And when survivors come forward, they’re doing so at immense personal cost.

And as we saw last week with the hashtag — #WhyIDidn’tComeForward [sic], I believe it was — there’s a lot reasons that women and other survivors don’t come forward. And so I don’t think that this is a problem that is specific to any one institution. Underage drinking happens everywhere, all across the country. Excessive drinking happens everywhere all across the country. And unfortunately, sexual assault happens everywhere. So I think this is a problem that we as a country need to think about and contend with.

But again, the most important thing and the focus I believe of the Holton-Arms community letter was just, “Dr. Blasey Ford, we’re here for you, we stand with you, we believe you, you need to be heard and there needs to be a thorough and independent investigation.”

AMY GOODMAN: Alexis, 1,100 women signed this letter. Talk about this number. What are the class sizes at Holton-Arms?

ALEXIS GOLDSTEIN: Holton-Arms is a very small school. I would say the class size is about 80 to 100, and the farther you go back in time, the smaller those class sizes are. So 1,100 women on a letter is a very, very large chunk of our community. So this is not a small portion of our community; this is a very significant chunk. So it shows you just how large of a presence within the Holton-Arms community there is standing with Dr. Blasey Ford and saying, “We support you.”

AMY GOODMAN: Alexis, I want to thank you for being with us. Who are the other people who will be a front of the Supreme Court today as you head off?

ALEXIS GOLDSTEIN: I believe there’s is a whole slew of different organizations. To be honest with you, Amy, I just saw this on Twitter, so I just wanted to be there in person with them and show my support. But it’s multiple groups, and I’m not sure of the name of all of them.

AMY GOODMAN: Finally, Alexis, this is the seventh anniversary of Occupy, and you were very involved with Occupy Wall Street and really involved with giving economic analysis to the economic meltdown that took place in this country. I was wondering how you compare the Occupy movement to what we’re seeing today, the whole #metoo movement around this country, and especially that is expressing support like your school has. And by the way, has the management of the school expressed support for Dr. Ford? But if you could compare the two.

ALEXIS GOLDSTEIN: I will say briefly that the head of the Holton-Arms school, Susanna Jones, did issue a statement saying that they were proud of Dr. Blasey Ford for coming forward.

I was a part of Occupy as someone who worked on Wall Street. I had first-hand knowledge of what it was like to work on Wall Street. I worked on Wall Street for seven years at Morgan Stanley, Merrill Lynch and Deutsche Bank. And in some ways, I guess that is the parallel that I would draw. The #metoo movement is about women and survivors with personal experience with sexual assault and telling their own stories and speaking their truth about what happened to them. I suppose that, at least for me personally, is — the main parallel is it’s about folks with personal experience coming forward and saying, “Here is my truth.”

But I would say the other parallel, I suppose, is just people standing up and speaking their beliefs and trying to say, “This is how we want to build a better world,” whether it is a better world that has more economic fairness or a world without sexual assault.

AMY GOODMAN: Alexis Goldstein, thanks so much. Holton-Arms school alum who is one of the women who spearheaded a letter now signed by 1,100 Holton-Arms school alumni that went to West Virginia Senator Capito, who also is a Holton-Arms school alum.

We’re going to turn back now to Jodi Jacobson, and then we’re going to turn to Professor Barbara Ransby in Chicago, who was involved with support for Anita Hill in 1991. But Jodi Jacobson, president and editor-in-chief of Rewire, there is so much to talk about here. So much news has come out.

In The New Yorker piece that came out last night that detailed the accusations of the second woman to say that Brett Kavanaugh, in his first year at Yale, sexually assaulted her, pushed his genitals in her face, humiliating her and assaulting her — in that same New Yorker piece is a quote from Mark Judge’s ex-girlfriend, Elizabeth Rasor. I’m not sure — or Rasor — how do you pronounce her name? R-A-S-O-R.

Now, Mark Judge was a friend of Kavanaugh. He wrote the book Wasted about his high school years. In it, there is a person called Bart O’Kavanaugh, which is clearly a thinly veiled reference to his friend. And The New Yorker piece quotes Mark Judge’s ex-girlfriend, Elizabeth Rasor, saying Rasor recalled that Judge had told her ashamedly of an incident that involved him and other boys taking turns having sex with a drunk woman. Rasor said that Judge seemed to regard it as fully consensual. She said Judge did not name others involved in the incident, and she had no knowledge Kavanaugh participated, but Rasor was disturbed by the story and noted it undercut Judge’s protestations about the sexual innocence of Georgetown Prep. Rasor stressed, “Under normal circumstances, “I wouldn’t reveal information that was told in confidence.” But she said, “I can’t stand by and watch him lie.”

JODI JACOBSON: Yeah. So Mark Judge and Brett Kavanaugh I believe are still friends. They have been friends for a very long time. Mark Judge has written prolifically, not just in the one book you mention, but in others, about his alcoholism throughout his teen years and how wild his life was. He has refused to come and testify on the Senate Judiciary Committee. GOP has refused to subpoena him. Now, he has been identified by this woman in The New Yorker as having told her stories of what are effectively gang rapes. Because as the story is told, they get a woman drunk and gang rape her.

So I think this alone merits investigation. And I think it is part of the reason that Judge doesn’t want to come before the committee — because he would be under oath and be questioned about these things, and he’s got his own lengthy written record of all of these activities. I think also, you’ve got this hint by Michael Avenatti. It’s not corroborated. I don’t know whether or not he has actual evidence or if he’s sort of trying to get into the drama on this. I don’t know. But he —

AMY GOODMAN: Let me go into — when you’re talking about Michael Avenatti — this is very important — the lawyer for Stormy Daniels. This is the list of questions that Michael Avenatti says should be asked of Brett Kavanaugh. And these were released in a series of emails he had with the person you were talking about earlier, Mike Davis…


AMY GOODMAN: — the staffer on the Senate Judiciary Committee. This is what Michael Avenatti says should be asked of Judge Kavanaugh. One, “Did you ever target one or more women for sex or rape at a house party?” Did you ever assist Mark Judge or others in doing so?” Two, “Did you ever attend any house party during which a woman was gang raped or used for sex by multiple men?” Three, “Did you ever witness a line of men outside a bedroom at any house party where you understood a woman was in the bedroom being raped or taken advantage of?” Four, “Did you ever participate in any sexual conduct with a woman at a house party whom you understood to be intoxicated or under the influence of drugs?” And five, “Did you ever communicate with Mark Judge or anyone else about your participation in a ‘train’ involving intoxicated women?” Six, “Did you ever object or attempt to prevent one or more men from participating in the rape or taking advantage of a woman at any house party?”


AMY GOODMAN: These are the questions Michael Avenatti says the senators must ask.

JODI JACOBSON: He’s implying that he has got information about this. Again, it’s uncorroborated — he hasn’t brought forth any person — but it connects back to the story that Rasor told in The New Yorker, and it also connects back to other pieces of The New Yorker story and other reporting around Kavanaugh at Yale. He was part of a fraternity that was known for very heavy drinking. It had a somewhat — I won’t repeat the name on TV, but its sort of colloquial name was very offensive to women. He’s part of the fraternity that marched around saying, “No means yes, and yes means anal” and used to walk around with a flag made of women’s underwear and bras. So his life trajectory at least —

AMY GOODMAN: The all-male secret society was Truth and Courage. And it was that “t” and “c” that colloquially referred to an insult to women.

JODI JACOBSON: Yes. So again, there’s sort of a bigger pattern here that if you were really interested in investigating — let’s just remind ourselves that Brett Kavanaugh does not have a great deal of credibility anyway, because several people knowledgeable about his testimony on other issues have claimed that he perjured himself — like Lisa Graves, who was chief counsel during the time that he was at the White House in the Bush administration.

He somehow pulled up calendars from high school this weekend but couldn’t find emails that he was copied on during his relationship with Judge Kozinski, who was widely known for harassing women and sending pornographic material around to his clerks. So there are very selective memories going on here. Talk about selective memory? Kavanaugh seems to have a very selective memory and only brings forth those things that seem to hold up his end of the story.

AMY GOODMAN: There is so much that continues to be revealed. I want to thank you, Jodi, for coming, and especially our condolences on the death of your brother.

JODI JACOBSON: Thank you. Thank you so much.

AMY GOODMAN: Thank you for coming here in this difficult time. Jodi Jacobson, president and editor in chief of Rewire. We will link to her latest piece, GOP Wants ‘Aunt Lydia’ and Attack-Dog Staffer to Question Dr. Blasey Ford. This is Democracy Now! When we come back, we will be joined by Professor Barbara Ransby, who will talk about her role in gaining support, particularly of African American women, for Anita Hill, back during the Anita Hill-Clarence Thomas hearings. Stay with us.


A critical message, before you scroll away

You may not know that Truthout’s journalism is funded overwhelmingly by individual supporters. Readers just like you ensure that unique stories like the one above make it to print – all from an uncompromised, independent perspective.

At this very moment, we’re conducting a fundraiser with a goal to raise $37,000 in the next 5 days. So, if you’ve found value in what you read today, please consider a tax-deductible donation in any size to ensure this work continues. We thank you kindly for your support.