Skip to content Skip to footer

CDC Director Overheard Saying Everything Trump’s COVID Adviser Says “Is False”

The adviser, Scott Atlas, has been pushing the White House to adopt a “herd immunity” approach to the COVID pandemic.

President Trump listens as White House coronavirus adviser Scott Atlas speaks during a press conference in the Brady Briefing Room of the White House on September 23, 2020, in Washington, D.C.

During a phone conversation on a commercial airplane late last week overheard by an NBC News reporter, the head of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention slammed one of the White House’s top Covid-19 advisers for providing President Donald Trump and the U.S. public with misleading information about the deadly pandemic.

“Everything he says is false,” CDC Director Dr. Robert Redfield told a colleague while on a flight from Atlanta to Washington, D.C. on Friday, NBC News reported Monday morning. Redfield, a Trump appointee, later acknowledged to NBC that he was referring to Dr. Scott Atlas, a neuroradiologist with no expertise in infectious diseases or epidemiology.

Brought aboard the administration’s Covid-19 task force in August after reportedly catching Trump’s attention with his frequent appearances on Fox News, Atlas has been pushing the White House to adopt a so-called “herd immunity” approach to the coronavirus pandemic — a strategy public health experts warn would cause millions of additional deaths. Atlas has also publicly questioned the effectiveness of face coverings in preventing the spread of coronavirus.

“Since his addition to the task force, Atlas has become the medical expert who spends the most time with the president, and his profile has been elevated in recent weeks by his appearing in the White House briefing room when Trump speaks with reporters,” NBC reported. “There is a concern among Redfield and others that Atlas continually briefs the president and misrepresents what other health experts have said in sworn testimony, according to a member of the task force.”

As epidemiologist Eric Feigl-Ding noted on Twitter, Atlas “has been spreading misinformation for a long time,” including by falsely stating that coronavirus poses “no risk” to children.

Despite Atlas’ complete lack of experience in the field of infectious diseases, Trump has cited the radiologist in an effort to legitimize his false claims about the coronavirus.

“A lot of people do agree with me,” Trump said during an ABC News town hall in defense of his insistence that the U.S. is “rounding the corner” on the pandemic. “You look at Scott Atlas, you look at some of the other doctors that are highly — from Stanford.”

But in a letter about a week ahead of Trump’s town hall, dozens of Atlas’ former colleagues at Stanford University Medical School denounced the White House adviser for spreading “falsehoods and misrepresentations of the science” in a variety of areas, from mask use to his promotion of herd immunity.

“Many of his opinions and statements run counter to established science and, by doing so, undermine public-health authorities and the credible science that guides effective public health policy,” the Stanford faculty members warned.

We’re not going to stand for it. Are you?

You don’t bury your head in the sand. You know as well as we do what we’re facing as a country, as a people, and as a global community. Here at Truthout, we’re gearing up to meet these threats head on, but we need your support to do it: We must raise $16,000 before midnight to ensure we can keep publishing independent journalism that doesn’t shy away from difficult — and often dangerous — topics.

We can do this vital work because unlike most media, our journalism is free from government or corporate influence and censorship. But this is only sustainable if we have your support. If you like what you’re reading or just value what we do, will you take a few seconds to contribute to our work?