Part of the Series
Planet or Profit
Lliam Hildebrand says he had a moment of clarity during an apprenticeship at a steel fabricating shop in Victoria, Canada. He was learning the metal-working skills he would need to become a boilermaker and eventually move on to work on the many steel vessels — including furnaces, pipelines, cokers and exchangers — that make up the oil industry’s vast infrastructure in the tar sands fields of Alberta, Canada.
During that apprenticeship, Hildebrand would come into the fabricating shop and see a pressure vessel on one side of the shop being made for the tar sands, and at the same time, on the other side of the shop, his own project — a wind farm weather station. Hildebrand says the contrast between the two ventures struck him sharply as he walked into the shop one morning. That was the moment when he realized, “We are the trade — the building trade — that’s really going to help address [climate change].”
From then on he has felt as though he’s been living two lives. Coming out of his apprenticeship, he started looking for jobs in the renewable sector but was unable to find work. Six years ago, he reluctantly decided to apply his skills where there were plenty of jobs: the Canadian tar sands fields.
But after years of working in an industry that one leading climate scientist has called “the biggest carbon bomb on the planet,” Hildebrand came to realize that he was not the only oil worker in Alberta who felt “guilty about developing the infrastructure that is creating climate change.”
Opportunity in the Oil Plunge
Last spring, when oil prices began to fall, Hildebrand banded together with like-minded co-workers and began building an oil and gas worker-led nonprofit called Iron & Earth, which officially launched this month during a press conference in Edmonton, Canada. Through the nonprofit, the tar sands workers hope to help others who have been laid off diversify their skill sets and facilitate the necessary training to transition them to the renewable energy sector. They also want to help incorporate renewable energy projects into tar sands workers’ current scope of work.
Hildebrand and others seized on the opportunity opened up by the oil price plunge, which he says created an “urgent need to diversify our trade skills and our energy grid, as we were being really impacted by our dependence on these carbon-based energy jobs.” According to the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers, more than 100,000 jobs were lost there in 2015 due to the global drop in oil prices.
“We are a group of workers who not only want to diversify our work scope based on job need, but also based on a values-based mission, to ensure that we’re creating and building a future that’s going to be sustainable,” Hildebrand told Truthout. “The drop in oil prices was certainly a catalyst to help amplify these conversations, and created the pressure to … create a catch-all organization that’s going to make projects happen and get workers’ hands on some renewable energy projects.”
Moreover, not every oil worker with experience in Alberta’s tar sands needs to retrain in order to transition to the renewable sector, according to Hildebrand, who says a lot of trades are “directly transferable.” Hildebrand has worked on several renewable energy projects himself, including a biomass plant and the wind farm weather station that inspired him during his apprenticeship. “I didn’t require any retraining for that. All I required was the blueprints and the steel and the facility to build it,” he said.
From Tar Sands to Solar Skills
Iron & Earth’s first project is its Solar Skills campaign to facilitate the retraining of 1,000 laid-off electricians from Alberta’s oil industry to help build 100 solar installations on public buildings throughout the province beginning this fall. In the future, as the group takes on different campaigns focused on geothermal, biomass, biofuel and wind energy, they hope to attract other kinds of oil and gas workers, such as pipefitters and iron workers, as well as workers from other building trades, to retrain in those sectors.
The group is asking for provincial funding from Alberta’s New Democratic Party government for its first campaign. But according to Hildebrand, the project has even drawn interest from the likes of oil giant Enbridge, which sent a representative to the group’s first press event last week. Another solar company, Suncor, has also expressed interest. “Right now we’re just trying to focus on a specific, tangible campaign because we’re still young and small and trying to stay within our capacity,” Hildebrand said.
One electrician who currently works in the tar sands industry and plans to undergo training via the Solar Skills campaign is Iron & Earth’s director, Adam Cormier, from Newfoundland, Canada. Cormier, who’s worked as an electrician for seven years, plans to grow the organization on the country’s east coast by starting a Newfoundland chapter and connecting with oil and gas workers and renewable energy companies there.
Cormier has been working in extractive industries for about two years now, not only in Alberta, but also in the Labrador region of Newfoundland, where he worked on mining infrastructure. As an electrician in the tar sands, he provides temporary power during construction processes, and also tests motors and lights. He hopes that, through Iron & Earth’s Solar Skills campaign, he will one day be able to oversee the installation of solar panels.
The oil plunge hit Newfoundland hard. The oil-dependent province is facing a deficit of nearly $2 billion, and thousands of skilled workers have been laid off since the price drop began. However, Cormier sees this transitional time as a necessary moment, independent of prices. “The fact of the matter is, even if oil prices go back up, and they probably will, Canada still needs to meet its commitment under the Paris [United Nations 21st Conference of Parties] agreement. So, regardless of whether or not oil prices stay low or go back up, we need to diversify our energy economy to include renewables,” Cormier says.
Cormier, like Hildebrand, began having misgivings about working in the oil and gas industry as he learned more about the scientific consensus regarding human-caused climate disruption. “For me, being aware of [climate change], and at the same time working in the oil sands … it really gets you thinking about your contribution to either the problem or the solution.”
A Blue-Green Transition
The tar sands workers are also hoping to attract the support of their own labor unions, seeking alliances with the International Brotherhood of Boilermakers and the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, for a start. They don’t have any official partnerships yet, but have arranged meetings with union leaders and representatives from renewable energy companies to talk about how they can work together to diversify their trades.
Hildebrand says that while some of the largest unions in Canada have been supportive of renewable energy development, a majority of the country’s building-trade unions haven’t been as enthusiastic. “We’re hopeful that we can be a catalyst to help our unions realize … the enormous opportunity that renewable energy development has for our trade, because a large portion of renewable energy development is going to be in industrial steel projects,” Hildebrand says.
One strategy for appealing to organized labor is to draw attention to changes in working conditions: The renewable energy offers a decrease in occupational health hazards. Studies show that oil and gas workers are killed on the job at a fatality rate that is nearly seven times greater than the rate for many other industries, and that oil and gas workers are exposed to greater levels of carcinogens like benzene. (Of course, the renewable sector isn’t perfect either, safety-wise: “There’s no doubt that working in renewables is going to be much cleaner than working in oil and gas, but we’re still going to have a lot of dangers,” Cormier cautioned.)
The workers of Iron & Earth hope to develop relationships with all of the major building trade unions in Alberta and Canada more widely, and as they grow, reach out to unions and workers across the continent, including the U.S., where the oil plunge has also affected thousands of workers in shale fields. Those workers, too, are transitioning to the renewable sector amid massive layoffs.
U.S. Oil Workers Transition Amid Shale Bust
With oil prices remaining below $30 per barrel well into 2016, oil and gas companies in the U.S. are continuing to lay off workers. The oil, gas and coal industries in the U.S. saw employment drop by 6.6 percent in 2015, with 104,514 jobs lost, an increase from 4,137 in 2014.
The brunt of that loss has fallen on southern states, Texas chief among them. The state ranked third in employment growth in 2014 but plummeted to 32nd place last year. But as oil and gas loses in Texas, wind energy in the state is thriving — and laid-off oil and gas workers are finding jobs in the state’s wind and solar sectors.
According to the American Wind Energy Association, Texas leads the nation in wind power, with more than 17,000 megawatts of wind energy generation and more than 5,000 megawatts of wind generation under construction. Solar is moving more slowly but is still finding a place in Texas, ranking ninth in the nation for solar power in 2015.
Mortenson Construction recruiter Matthew Ehrenberg told Truthout that the Minneapolis-based company has a number of solar and wind projects across Texas and Utah, including its Alamo 7 solar plant in Haskell, Texas. Ehrenberg said the company hired about 500 individuals to work on the project as of March 21, and while he couldn’t pin down an exact percentage of workers who were hired from the oil and gas sector, he called the percentage significant.
A workforce-development board for the West Central Texas region arranged a hiring event for Mortenson, during which the company hired about 60 individuals. According to business resource consultant Steve Collins, about 60 to 75 percent of those hired were from the oil field.
Ehrenberg says the company conducted a job survey in January that showed it hired about 130 people from the Haskell area for the Alamo 7 project, with “a big portion” being “oil and gas industry folks.” Another 400 people, many from the oil and gas sector, are working on the company’s Alamo 6 project in Pecos County. The company also recently hired about 90 people to work on a plant in Utah — another state that has experienced oil and gas layoffs.
Ehrenberg agreed with Hildebrand of Iron & Earth that oil workers’ skills translate well to solar projects.
While oil and gas workers transitioning to the renewable sector may not make as much money as they did when oil prices were high, in the long run, their new jobs may prove to be more stable. “One of the biggest complaints that I get from applicants is that [oil and gas] is up and down,” Ehrenberg said. “If they’re on an oil rig, one week they’re working and the next week they’re not working, and so it’s … very frustrating for families, but … [solar is] not based on a commodity price.”
Ehrenberg and Cormier expect the industry to continue to expand across the South in the coming months as oil prices remain low. “Diversifying our economy to include renewables is a win-win-win,” says Cormier. “It’s a win for our personal health, both as workers on the job sites and the overall benefit that is transmitted to society from having less … coal plants, and it’s a win for the planet and for future generations to come.”
Not everyone can pay for the news. But if you can, we need your support.
Truthout is widely read among people with lower incomes and among young people who are mired in debt. Our site is read at public libraries, among people without internet access of their own. People print out our articles and send them to family members in prison — we receive letters from behind bars regularly thanking us for our coverage. Our stories are emailed and shared around communities, sparking grassroots mobilization.
We’re committed to keeping all Truthout articles free and available to the public. But in order to do that, we need those who can afford to contribute to our work to do so.
We’ll never require you to give, but we can ask you from the bottom of our hearts: Will you donate what you can, so we can continue providing journalism in the service of justice and truth?